
SHARED CULTURE
A consensus of individual values
By Joan Richardson
Results, May 2001.
Copyright, National Staff Development Council, 2001. All rights reserved.
Principals are the primary shapers of school culture, in both large and small ways.
Principals send large cultural messages to staff and students with every decision regarding budgets, curriculum, instruction, as well as interactions with central office and community leaders. But principals also send hundreds of small cultural messages to students and teachers every day. In every interaction with a student or teacher, a principal telegraphs a message about his or her expectations for that school. That gives principals enormous opportunities to shape a schools culturefor good or ill.
Some principals provide cultural leadership intuitively, said Kent Peterson, professor of educational administration at the University of Wisconsin and co-author with Terrence Deal of Shaping School Culture (Jossey-Bass, 1999). But all principals can learn to consciously identify culture-making opportunities and use them to influence teachers, students, and parents to move in a new direction, he said.
Peterson recalled one principal who recognized that he did not intuitively know when a "cultural moment" was presenting itself. So, using a 3x5 index card, he wrote down five elements of the school culture that he wanted to improve. He stuck the card in his shirt pocket and pulled it out throughout his day as a way to remind himself of questions he could ask.
"You can find ways to encourage yourself to be more conscious of this. Eventually, it becomes internalized," Peterson said.
Peterson also recalled shadowing a principal who found ways to blend administrative tasks with opportunities to influence attitudes in his building. This principal had to provide central office with the total number of ceiling tiles in his building. Rather than assign that task to a maintenance employee, the principal assumed the job himself. The principals arrival in each classroom was, of course, a big event to both students and teachers. In each classroom, he asked what students were learning that day and asked to see student workthen he counted the ceiling tiles. He had taken responsibility for a mundane task because it allowed him to connect with every classroom in the building and to send a message about the importance of students work.
Although principals are enormously influential, they alone cannot shape the culture of a school, Peterson said. "Culture is the accumulation of many individuals values and norms. It is a consensus about whats important. Its the groups expectations, not just an individuals expectations. Its the way everyone does business," he said.
Teachers are especially important in influencing the direction of a schools culture. Teachers connect with other teachers, with their students, and with the parents of their students. When teachers are sending a shared cultural message, that message reverberates throughout the entire school community.
One schools story
Joan Vydra practically gushes about her school in suburban Chicago. "Its so awesome to walk in the door here," she said of Briar Glen School in Wheaton. The school with 480 students in grades K-5 is in Glen Ellyn Community Consolidated District 89.
As a veteran principal, Vydra believes no school can improve unless it has a culture that supports improvement and collaboration and a shared vision for what it wants to achieve. She also believes fervently that a school will improve only if it has a culture of caring. "If teachers dont feel cared about, they cant perform at optimum levels. If I care about the teachers, they will pass that on to the kids," she said.
When she arrived at Briar Glen five years ago, there was some tension in the school. Briar Glen, an award-winning school, had "wonderful teachers" who worked well within their teams, but spent most of their team time on organizational rather than instructional issues. Although wonderful things were happening in individual classrooms, there was little sense of an overall direction and no school improvement plan to guide their collective work. "There was no shared vision about what the school should be," she said.
Vydra began by telling the staff, "Im going to walk in your shoes for a year. Then, whatever changes we make, were going to make together." High on Vydras agenda was ensuring that teachers could do the work they were hired to do.
"I dont want anything on a teachers plate that doesnt belong there. I want them to focus on their students and on the goals of our school improvement plan."
For example, rather than overloading teachers with excessive testing data and expecting them to wade through it, Vydra winnows the data down to what each teacher needs to know. Then, when she meets with teachers, they are able to focus on individual children who need assistance, rather than swimming through irrelevant numbers.
When teachers agreed that they wanted parents to have a better understanding of what children are expected to know and be able to do, Vydra wrote a grant that would enable her to give teachers summer stipends to prepare standards-based newsletters for distribution during the school year. "If Im asking them to improve their communication with parents, I want to remove obstacles that prevent them from doing that. Time is an obstacle and this was a way to work around that," she said.
Listening to parents
As she listened to teachers, Vydra also listened to parents. It was parents perceptions that not enough teachers attended the parent-sponsored events. Vydra asked parents which events were most important for teacher attendance. From a long list, parents identified four significant events.
With that list, Vydra approached teachers and said, "You dont have to do this, but this is very important to our parents. If were going to build our learning community, this is a good first step. If youll try to attend these specific events, Ill tell parents that you wont be at all the other events and meetings."
At the same time, Vydra thanked the teachers for their willingness to attend events by informing them that she would not enforce previously mandatory starting and ending times for the work day. "I trust these teachers. They dont need to be told what time to get here or when they can leave. Theyre going to be here."
The teachers quickly responded to the request and have made teacher attendance at the identified events part of the cultural norm.
Nothing is perfect
During her five years at Briar Glen, Vydra admits to missteps along the way. An enthusiastic advocate for school and classroom newsletters, she announced in a faculty meeting during her second year at the school that she would be sharing teachers classroom newsletters. "I found something good in every newsletter, but they hated it," she said. "Nobody wanted to be put out in front."
"Were more ready for that now. But Im still careful to praise teams, not individuals," she said.
When personal praise is warranted, she writes personal notes instead of making a public statement. "In meetings, I might mention the example without mentioning the name," she said.
Vydra acknowledges that if she had entered a school with a "toxic culture," she would have responded differently. "If its a broken school and kids are being hurt and there is low achievement, there have to be some top-down initiatives.
"Shaping a culture takes time. Anything that is top-down will last only as long as the leader stays in that office. Then those ideas will evaporate and everything will go right back to the way it was," Vydra said.
But culture stays. "Culture protects a school and teachers from willy-nilly fads and from leaders who think they own the day," she said.